By Thom Nadeau
of
Notable Trials
Sacramento County Superior Court Judge Thomas Cecil listened for three hours Friday afternoon to Elk Grove City Councilman
Patrick Hume and his former flame Constance Conley bitterly complain in excruciating detail their on-again, off-again love-hate affair.
When they were finally done accusing, denying and being unable to recall, Cecil said he would rule by Oct. 8 on if the politically active Conley and Hume must remain apart.
Their rocky relationship had lasted about five years – years marked alternately by break-ups and make-ups and break-ups again.
During one especially acrimonious estrangement Hume obtained a stay-away order that barred Conley from contacting him. In that same interim Hume, 38, took up with a new girlfriend, one Lisa Lent.
At the same time, however, Hume and Conley blatantly ignored the stay-away court order and attended political events and fund-raisers together, Conley’s attorney Paige Hibbert elicited through questioning.
“Hundreds and hundreds” of phone calls, emails, text messages ensued, Hume and Conley admitted, under questioning by Hume’s attorney, Ron Peters.
Not only did Hume and Conley exchange many calls and messages, some individual conversations were extraordinarily long.
Telephone records showed (and Hume confirmed) that one particular call between himself and Conley lasted eight hours and 10 minutes.
The calls, messages and emails sometimes became nasty, with Conley make unflattering accusations against Hume and Lent.
When Conley took the stand, she produced a three-ring binder packed four inches thick with printouts of emails and other exchanges between herself and Hume.
Hume’s demeanor on the stand was testy and his answers were curt. At one point, apparently impatient with how things were proceeding, he began testifying directly to the judge.
Peters, a seasoned and respected attorney, immediately cut Hume short, telling him in very few words that it was the attorney not the witness who led the questioning.
That odd exchange was but one of several uncommon events highlighting the courtroom action in Hume v. Conley, case #06CP01317.
Judge Cecil lays out issues for resolution